People clearly have differing ideas, but, even when presented with the same information, people can interpret it differently based on their currently-held worldview. Here is the most classic example I can come up with in terms orthopedic thinking: shoulder impingement. The predominant worldview (in the US at least) is that muscles, joints, tendons, and neural patterns around the shoulder are functioning improperly as a unit and therefore during overhead movements the subacromial space is impinged causing pain. My view is that in over 90% of cases one specific thing is not working correctly.
The prevailing treatment for the common worldview is simultaneously stretching or releasing one or more muscles, loading certain tendons, strengthening many muscles, and moving certain joints. I remember I used to give patients at least seven things to do at one time when I had that belief system, which I was taught.
My current view is that most patients need to move just one particular joint or tendon. That particular movement is often, but not always, included in the array of movements listed above, which is interesting but not surprising since the normal treatment includes so many things! So if people get better with the standard approach, people believe it’s correct.
My understanding now, however, is that the reason they got better is because they included the one thing they needed - and the rest was superfluous and, at worst, a waste of time and resources. My patients with shoulder pain with overhead movements almost always get just one exercise to do at a time, which may or may not change over time. (For me, what other clinicians diagnose as shoulder impingement, I diagnose as several different things: cervical derangement, thoracic derangement, shoulder derangement, and shoulder contractile dysfunction.)
It’s interesting to think about how our belief systems can inform how we understand the evidence. Clearly those who believe the predominant worldview and those who believe the MDT-leaning view interpret the fact that people get better with standard shoulder impingement treatment very differently. As I wrote recently: I am interested in what works, but I’m more interested in what works best. - -Laura
Learn more about the world of diagnosing and treating orthopedics here!